GenderFAQ - or, more likely, never asked questions
Q1. So are you some sort of hermaphrodite, then?
The short answer is no. The long answer is no, too.
I identify myself as an androgyne. This has nothing to do, in my case, with any ambiguity of my sex organs.
In any case, I understand that the word "hermaphrodite" is on the way out, "intersex" is pretty mainstream, and the new term in some quarters is DSD (Disorders of sexual development). So there, better learn about the sex-and-gender alphabet soup.
But that's by the by.
I don't know who first said it, but it's become a pretty widespread saying, "Sex is between your legs, gender is between your ears". Genetically, that is, from birth, I was male and still am. My own biological sex for me is as simple as that. I realise it's not as simple as that for everyone, but it is for me.
That has only a remote bearing on my gender, which is a complex cultural/mental/"spiritual" - er - matrix. It's about how I don't identify with the whole male Thang, which I'd caricature as risk-taking, aggressive, dominating. Nor is it an alternative to espouse 100% femininity, which I could also caricature as nurturing, sweet and submissive. I am not setting out to insult real men and women by saying this, and I don't expect to meet anyone with 100% of these characteristics.
I don't respond at all well, and never did, to the "all boys together" situations I've sometimes found myself in at school, after work and in my own leisure time. "Come on, lads", and such expressions, I've always felt, somehow leave me out. So do greetings like "Hi, girls" in some transgender settings that I've come across. How do you know I call myself a girl? In fact I don't.
That does throw you up against the limitations of the English language, and I don't have any answers to that one, short of inventing some intergender language that nobody would understand. I'm not talking about "gender-neutral" pronouns and the like. That's a good idea, probably doomed to failure outside some very specialised environments, but anyway it still doesn't make it for me. I'm not neutral, I'm positively an androgyne, and I haven't got any pronouns for that.
Q2. Why don't you look like an androgyne?
What does an androgyne look like? Gender is between your ears, you know, not in your makeup bag.
Appearance doesn't tell you much about a person's gender, unless they've gone out of their way to make it so. I know some rock stars have taken on a kind of ambiguous appearance - Sonny and Cher come to mind, as does David Bowie. Does that actually make them androgynes? No, it doesn't at all. I wouldn't know whether any of them identify that way. I'd contend that such an appearance may be an expression of gender, but it doesn't have to be.
In everyday life, I probably look like a half-way regular guy. I have long hair on my head (feminine?) and facial hair on my face (masculine?), and probably hark back to our ape forbears more than many. Both kinds of hair just grow there without much effort from me,
At the same time, my choice of clothes does to some extent reflect a feminine streak. I like more colour than conventional male dress allows. I don't mind patterns so long as they're not too Euclidian - I don't go in for stripes and squares. i like more curved, flowing, Mandelbrot-like shapes, and don't mind if there are 17 million colours involved. Maybe my shirts are too silky for a rough lad, but not frilly enough to be blousy and woman-like.
In private, or somewhere like the beach or a park, I might hazard a robe or a kaftan, and run about in a pair of women's panties. Nobody seems to care, amazingly enough.
Q3. So does that mean you're a crossdresser?
Tricky one, that. Someone born male in our culture is not supposed to wear girl's panties or skirts, but sometimes I do just that. I'll leave it up to you to say whether that's crossdressing. What am I crossing from and to? that's difficult to define, and probably doesn't matter. Why is it such a big deal anyway if someone who's supposed to be a guy wears a garment without two leg bits? I'm fully in favour of skirts for men in any case. They're comfortable, and look better on me than any ratty old business suit.
It does seem that in the transgender world, being a crossdresser means more than wearing some garments from the opposite sex. To do it properly, you need also to adopt the make-up / toiletry habits of the opposite sex as well, and the shoes and the voice, and the walk, and maybe the shaving. I haven't done any of that, nor do I see the relevance.
Q4. So you're just lazy, aren't you, can't be bothered to make the transition? Not like my friend Tammy who spent $15 million on reassignment surgery. She's really got the courage of her convictions.
I'm not making any transition, I'm already there. In some sectors of the transgender world, it does seem to be a point of honour to make it out in the streets "passing" as the opposite sex. No insult to anyone who's on that particular journey, but it is not mine. I don't want anyone imposing that on me.
Similarly, I'm not booking up for any surgery because I have no need or desire to have a different set of misleading sexual organs! I do know some people who have really got to look at that issue because I'm sure they were born in the wrong body. I may have been born in the wrong culture, but that's a whole other story.
Q5. Are you gay?
As it happens, I'm bi-sexual. As far as I can tell, this is pretty much separate from my gender concerns. In some ways, it works pretty well, because both male and female partners have had something to offer that I've loved and identified with . This isn't something I know technically how to answer completely, but I take it that some completely straight people are androgynes too, and some who are a lot further along the gay spectrum may be as well. But it's helpful to look at sexuality and gender identity as two separate continua.
Q6. I still don't get it. Are you transgender or not?
In many ways not. I'm not trans anything in the sense of crossing to something else.
On the other hand, it's politically tempting to ally myself with other people who question and challenge the male/female gender norms. So I don't mind being included, just so long as I don't have to take on the expectations of other people. I suppose the word "genderqueer" is the best to cover this political dimension.
Q6. So are you madly spiritual then?
I don't know where this comes from, but in a lot of androgyne contexts I come across the assumption that someone like me is supposed to be wildly spiritual. Yet another idea from other people that I can't take on board.
Maybe if I'd been born in Samoa or in a Native American community this would have more meaning. In any case, I have real problems with words like "spirituality" being used in the casual way in which they sometimes are. Please define what you mean.
Well, my brain is telling me to stop. I've probably opened enough cans of worms for one day anyway, and will return to some of these topics as time rumbles on.
Call me Nicola or Nicholas, I don't really mind!
Current Mood: working